A frictionless AI utopia could offer us everything but the essential experience of being human. By attempting to remove the rough edges of life, we may ultimately remove ourselves.
In early 2000 I started working for a company called “The Stock Market” in New York City.
At the interview, I discovered it was a stock photography agency and had nothing to do with Wall Street. I fell in love with the people and the work and enjoyed the photos but quickly tired of the most standard ones. The excessively-bright smiles on the faces of flawless families on white-sandy beaches and the overly-earnest handshakes of executives in glass-walled boardrooms were huge sellers but made my skin crawl.
These photos were technically flawless. The lighting was intentional; the composition was disciplined; every wayward wrinkle or blemish was meticulously retouched out of existence. Eventually, the perfection became both invisible and oppressive.
I learned from this experience that when everything is optimised, nothing is interesting and I’m seeing the ghost of that era haunting our modern AI zeitgeist.
When everything is optimised, nothing is interesting.
The best art helps us recognise ourselves in all our human imperfection. AI-generated content is leading us towards a new kind of aesthetic misery. It’s slick and beautiful, bearing none of the scars of reality. The writing is crisp and precise, always finding le mot juste—the perfect word for the moment. The imagery is hyper-real, the lighting is balanced and mathematically incontrovertible. The syntax is flawless.
Last week I passed a local cafe that previously had a charming albeit clumsily hand-drawn menu with slightly tired-looking but undeniably real photos. This time, I noticed an impressive new menu over the counter with with hyper-real, AI-generated images of wraps, salads, and smoothies. It looked very “professional” but felt hollow and dead. I felt like I’d walked into a simulation — the uncanny valley in menu form.
In a simulation, there is no friction. There is no resistance, no journey, no soul. It’s a hellscape.
Biological rejection of a world without struggle was famously articulated in 1999’s ground-breaking dystopian sci-fi thriller, The Matrix. Agent Smith explains why the first attempt at a simulated reality failed:
“Did you know that the first Matrix was designed to be a perfect human world? Where no one suffered, where everyone would be happy. It was a disaster. No one would accept the program. Entire crops were lost. Some believed we lacked the programming language to describe your perfect world. But I believe that, as a species, human beings define their reality through suffering and misery.”
…as a species, human beings define their reality through suffering and misery. — Agent Smith (The Matrix, 1999)
Rejection of a “perfect” world aligns with the core tenets of Buddhism, specifically the Three Marks of Existence, which define the human experience:
By its very nature, life is unsatisfying. We can be content with life, but never ultimately, permanently satisfied. Everything with a beginning has an end. All beings suffer. With time, a 5 star meal becomes waste and we become hungry again.
AI pretends this isn’t the case. It offers a digital stasis: an attempt to freeze the world in a state of permanent “perfection”. It seeks to solve Dukkha through algorithmic precision, smoothing over the dissatisfaction of life with perfectly optimised content.
In bypassing reality, AI bypasses the entire human experience.
The mythologist Joseph Campbell spoke of the “Hero’s Journey,” where the central arc is the ordeal the hero endures and their ultimate triumph over both adversity and their previous, lesser selves. Without the struggle, there can be no transformation.
Songwriter Nick Cave recently dismissed an AI-generated song written in his style as a “grotesque mockery of what it is to be human.” His reasoning was visceral: “Writing a good song is not mimicry, or replication, or pastiche, it is the opposite. It is an act of self-murder that destroys all one has strived to produce in the past. It is those dangerous, heart-stopping departures that catapult the artist beyond the limits of what he or she recognises as their known self.”
AI has no limitations from which to transcend; it has no “inner being” that has endured anything. It can replicate the surface of a masterpiece, but it can never replicate the audacity of a human being reaching beyond their own known limits.
I’ve been reading The Beauty of Everyday Things, which explores the Japanese philosophy of Wabi-sabi—the appreciation of the imperfect, the impermanent, and the incomplete. It finds beauty in Wabi (rustic simplicity) and Sabi (the patina of age and wear).
I feel this tension most deeply in my work with the live coding music community and their mantra of “Bad code only”.
AI music services promise a shorter path from your idea to a finished product by short-circuiting the struggle: the tentative first steps, the doubt, the practice, the false starts, the self-loathing, the relentless editing and tweaking, mastering and re-mastering, and the nail-biting moment of sharing it with the world.
AI satirist Ari Kuschnir has made a great reel featuring an 80’s-styled Sam Altman who says “Do you like making things, being creative, solving problems, getting good at something? Well, now you don’t have to!”
Musician and professional YouTube agitator, Adam Neely, has created a wonderfully scathing video analysis of this problem.
Live coding is a high-wire act of real-time expression. It is inherently vulnerable. Naked enthusiasm can outweigh expertise and a typo can create a beautifully unexpected rhythm, a stutter, or a marvelously mutant harmony.
In live coding, the “glitch” is our Kintsugi.
Kintsugi is the art of repairing broken pottery with lacquer mixed with powdered gold. Instead of disguising the cracks, it celebrates them, making the object more beautiful because of the intrusion of a chaotic breakage.
In a live set, those “rough edges” are our gold. They are the proof of the struggle. They are the scars that tell the audience: A human being is here, navigating this complexity in real-time. They are growing, wrangling, and overcoming right here, in this second.
As we automate more of our work and struggler, I believe we are heading toward a massive cultural pivot.
If perfection becomes a commodity—if anyone can generate a flawless, hyper-lit image or a perfectly structured essay in three seconds—then perfection will lose its value. It will become the “white noise” of the digital world.
I suspect we are going to see a premium placed on the “imperfect.” We will crave the hand-scrawled sign, the grainy photograph, and the unquantised rhythm. We will seek out the things that show the marks of effort and the evidence of a journey. We will finally realise that the “rough edges” aren’t flaws to be ironed out; they are the only way we know that something is real.
A Note of Irony: There is a certain cosmic joke in writing this. This entire meditation on the necessity of human struggle, the beauty of the glitch, and the hollowness of AI perfection was drafted with the assistance of an AI. I’ve since gone back in to fuck it and make it my own but it remains a kind of meta-commentary on my current reality: even my critiques of the simulation are being shaped by the simulation itself.
Maybe… just maybe, that’s the ultimate lesson. As Nick Cave wrote, there is a fire of hell in the eyes of the machine. Will we will use that fire to build a perfect cage, or use our own, fragile flame to find the light in the cracks?